Best Halloween Stores in New York: Your Ultimate Guide to Spooky Shopping

rickys halloween featured image

October’s here and you can feel that familiar chill in the air. It’s time to start thinking about your Halloween costume, isn’t it? New York, with its vibrant spirit and endless options, is bursting at the seams with stores that’ll cater to all your spooky needs.

Whether you’re looking for an outlandishly scary costume or simply a whimsical disguise, the Big Apple has got you covered! There are several top-notch Halloween stores scattered across the city that offer everything from high-quality costumes and props to dazzling decorations.

Let’s get ready to dive into this exciting world of make-believe. We’ve done some digging around for you and we’re excited to share our finds. Stay tuned as we unveil the best Halloween stores in New York that promise a spook-tacular shopping experience!

Exploring New York’s Top Halloween Stores

So, you’re in the Big Apple and Halloween is just around the corner. What better way to get in the spooky spirit than by exploring some of New York’s top Halloween stores? Let’s dive into a few that are sure to give you a frightfully good time.

First stop on your phantom tour has gotta be Abracadabra Superstore. Nestled in the heart of Manhattan, this place is more than just a costume shop—it’s an experience. They’ve got everything from classic witch hats to full-blown mascot outfits. But it doesn’t stop at costumes; you’ll find an array of magic tricks, prank gadgets and even theatrical makeup for all your ghoulish needs.

A few blocks away lies Gothic Renaissance – another must-see for Halloween enthusiasts. This specialty store might not have as wide a range as Abracadabra, but what they lack in quantity, they make up for with their unique collection of gothic wear and accessories. It’s perfect if you’re looking to add a dash of darkness to your outfit.

Now, if budget-friendly options are what you’re after then Ricky’s NYC should be on top of your list! With multiple locations sprawling across the city, Ricky’s offers affordable yet quality costumes and makeup kits that won’t break the bank but will definitely turn heads!

And let’s not forget about New York Costumes/Halloween Adventure located near East Village! This two-story mecca boasts room after room filled with costumes, wigs, props…you name it! Plus they operate year-round so no need to wait till October for those last-minute party plans.

Finally we’ve got Rubie’s Costume Company out in Queens – known worldwide for their extensive selection covering every era and genre possible! From superheroes to historical figures or even pets—they’ve got something for everyone!

So there ya have it folks – these are just some places where you can get your Halloween fix in New York. Whether you’re a local or just visiting, each one of these stores offers something unique to make your Halloween unforgettable!

Criteria for Choosing the Best Halloween Store

So, you’re on a mission to find the best Halloween store in New York. But wait a minute, how do you define ‘the best’? It’s not just about who has the biggest pumpkin or the most ghoulish decorations. Let’s break it down.

First up, variety is key. You want a store that offers an extensive range of costumes and accessories. Whether you’re dressing up as a classic witch or opting for a more obscure movie character, your ideal store should have something to suit your needs.

Next on our list is quality. Sure, you might only wear your costume once but no one wants their vampire fangs falling out halfway through the night! Look for stores that offer high-quality products that will last at least through your Halloween festivities.

Don’t forget about customer service! A great Halloween store should have knowledgeable staff willing to help with anything from sizing queries to makeup tips. They’ll be able to guide you in choosing the perfect costume and accessories.

Price points are also worth considering; after all, we all love a good deal! Seek out stores offering competitive prices without sacrificing on product quality or variety.

Lastly, take into account location and accessibility when choosing your go-to Halloween store. Ideally it would be centrally located or easily reachable by public transport… because nobody wants to drag home bags full of spooky stuff from across town!

And there you have it – variety, quality, customer service, price point and location are five criteria that can help YOU determine which Halloween store takes the crown as New York’s spookiest shopping destination!

Manhattan’s Must-Visit Halloween Stores

Hey there, Halloween enthusiasts! If you’re prowling the streets of Manhattan in search of the perfect spooky gear, we’ve got your back. Here are some must-visit Halloween stores that you simply can’t miss out on.

First up is Abracadabra NYC. Located in Flatiron District, it’s been a go-to spot for costumes and makeup since 1997. You’ll find an array of options from classic witches and vampires to trendy pop culture icons. Plus, they’ve got an impressive selection of props and decorations to turn your place into a haunted house.

Now let’s talk about Halloween Adventure. Nestled in East Village, this store is nothing short of a Halloween haven. They stock everything from adult and children’s costumes to wigs, masks, and accessories. What’s more? They’re open all year round!

Don’t forget to check out Rubie’s Costume Company, too! Known as the world’s largest designer and manufacturer of costumes, their flagship store in Richmond Hill never disappoints. Whether it’s superheroes or horror movie villains you’re after – Rubie’s has got you covered.

Last but not least is Gothic Renaissance in East Village – a unique boutique specializing in gothic clothing and accessories for those looking for something different this Halloween season.

Here’s a quick rundown:

Store Location
Abracadabra NYC Flatiron District
Halloween Adventure East Village
Rubie’s Costume Company Richmond Hill
Gothic Renaissance East Village

So fellow ghouls, now that you know where to head in Manhattan for your Halloween needs – what are you waiting for? Let these stores bewitch your shopping experience with their eerie yet exciting offerings!

Brooklyn’s Noteworthy Halloween Outlets

Hey, you’re in Brooklyn and Halloween is just around the corner. You’re probably thinking, “Where can I get the spookiest costumes or decorations?” Well, fear not! We’ve got a list of top Halloween stores that’ll make your holiday preparations a breeze.

First up on our list is Rubie’s Costume Co. They’ve been in business for over 60 years and boy, do they know their stuff! From classic witches to trending superheroes, they’ve got it all. Their range isn’t limited to adults either – kids’ costumes are aplenty!

Next stop? Brooklyn Superhero Supply Store. It may sound unconventional but trust us, their collection will amaze you! If you’re looking to stand out this year with a unique costume idea or want some superhero vibes added to your party decor – this place is your go-to.

Continuing our journey around the borough takes us to Oddities Flea Market. This isn’t your regular store but an entire market dedicated to all things odd and spooky. Here’s where you should head if vintage horror props are what you’re after.

Lastly, there’s Halloween Adventure nestled in East Village – technically not Brooklyn but we couldn’t resist mentioning it! With its extensive selection of both rentals and purchases available, it sure makes for one adventurous shopping experience!

  • Rubie’s Costume Co
  • Brooklyn Superhero Supply Store
  • Oddities Flea Market
  • Halloween Adventure

So hop on that subway or take a stroll down these streets because this season, Brooklyn’s ready to fulfill all your Halloween needs! But remember folks- while getting into the spirit of things is fun (and encouraged!), be respectful of others’ comfort zones too.
Remember: safety first… especially when ghosts and goblins are involved!

Queens’ Quintessential Spots for Halloween Shopping

If it’s that time of the year when pumpkins start appearing and you’re hunting for the perfect costume or decor, Queens has got your back. This New York borough is teeming with stores that cater to your Halloween needs. Let’s take a tour together through some of these amazing spots.

Halloween City in College Point is what you’d call a one-stop shop. It’s not just costumes they’ve got; their wide range includes everything from home decorations to party supplies. Another must-visit store is Rubie’s Costume Company in Richmond Hill. With over 60 years in business, you can trust them to sort out your costume woes.

Moving on, let’s head over to Spirit Halloween in Fresh Meadows. If you’re looking for something more unique than run-of-the-mill witches and vampires, this spot won’t disappoint! They’ve got an extensive collection of licensed merchandise including characters from popular movies and TV shows.

Don’t forget about Party City in Forest Hills either! Their well-organized selection makes shopping a breeze and their affordable prices will leave your wallet happy too!

Here’s a quick summary:

Store Location Speciality
Halloween City College Point One-stop Shop
Rubie’s Costume Company Richmond Hill Costumes
Spirit Halloween Fresh Meadows Unique Characters
Party City Forest Hills Organized Selection & Affordable Prices

So there you have it folks! Your guide to some quintessential spots for Halloween shopping in Queens. Whether it’s costumes, decorations or party supplies, these stores are sure to help make your spooky season unforgettable!

The Bronx and Staten Island: Hidden Gems for Halloween Gear

Hey, let’s talk about some under-the-radar spots in the city that never sleeps! If you’re in New York and hunting for the perfect Halloween gear, don’t overlook The Bronx and Staten Island. These boroughs might be slightly off Manhattan’s beaten path, but they’re bursting with gems waiting to be discovered.

First up is Frankie’s Carnival Time in the eastern part of The Bronx. This isn’t your average Halloween store. It has been around since 1957 – talk about steeped in history! You’ll find a huge selection of costumes here, from superheroes to horror villains. Plus, if you need decorations or party supplies, they’ve got you covered too.

Over on Staten Island there’s J & L Party Supply Inc., another must-visit destination for all things spooky. They take their Halloween seriously here – think animatronics that make your skin crawl and an impressive rack of masks that’ll transform you into anything (or anyone) else!

Looking for something a little different? Then you’ll love Abracadabra NYC located on South Street in Staten Island. This place is like stepping into another world where magic happens every day – even more so during the Halloween season! Here are some highlights:

  • A vast range of unique costumes
  • Magic tricks and illusions for sale
  • An array of wigs and accessories

And just when you thought we couldn’t pack any more excitement into this list, I present to you Rubie’s Costume Company over at Richmond Valley Road also on Staten island. It’s not only one of the largest costume manufacturers globally but also hosts an incredible array of choices right at our doorstep.

So next time you’re left thinking “where can I find good Halloween stores near me?”, remember these hidden gems tucked away in the corners of The Bronx and Staten Island. They might surprise you with their treasures!

Online Options: New York-Based E-commerce Halloween Stores

So you’re all set to celebrate this year’s Halloween but can’t find time to hunt down a costume shop in the Big Apple? No worries, we’ve got your back! Here are some top-notch online stores based right here in New York that’ll help you get your spook on.

Let’s kick things off with, also known as Halloween Adventure. They’re famous for their extensive collection of costumes, decorations, and accessories. Whether you’re looking for something classic like a witch or vampire, or want to go more unique with pop culture references, they’ve got it all.

Next up is Frank Bee Costume Center. Based in Bronx, this store has been around since 1957 and boasts one of the largest selections of kids’ costumes in the city. Their online store makes it easy to search by category so finding that perfect superhero or princess outfit for your little one is a breeze.

If high-quality masks are what you’re after, then The Horror Dome should be on your radar. Specializing solely in premium masks and props used by professional haunts and home haunters alike, their creations are truly out-of-this-world!

For those of you who prefer handmade items with an edge, there’s Etsy. This global marketplace features tons of New York-based sellers such as LoveCharlieJ which specializes in vintage-inspired dresses that double as great Halloween outfits.

And let’s not forget about Rubie’s, the world’s largest designer and manufacturer of costumes. You may have seen their products at local retailers but did you know they’re headquartered right here in Queens?

Here’s a quick summary:

  • (Halloween Adventure)
  • Frank Bee Costume Center
  • The Horror Dome
  • Etsy: LoveCharlieJ
  • Rubie’s

With these e-stores, you can enjoy a hassle-free Halloween shopping experience without stepping foot outside your door. Now that’s what we call convenience!

Conclusion: Making the Most of Your Halloween in New York

So, you’ve made it to the end of our spooky guide! You’re now equipped with all the insider knowledge needed to make your Halloween in New York truly unforgettable. From ghoulish garb to terrifying trinkets, New York’s Halloween stores have got you covered.

Remember, timing is everything when it comes to snagging those must-have items. The early bird gets the worm—or in this case—the best vampire cape! So don’t delay, start your haunting hunt today.

If you’re a DIY enthusiast looking for unique pieces to complete your homemade costume, places like Abracadabra Superstore and Halloween Adventure are sure to tickle your fancy. For those who prefer ready-to-wear costumes and accessories, Ricky’s NYC or Party City might be more up your alley.

But let’s not forget about the little ones! Stores like Rubie’s Costume Company and Frank Bee Costume Center offer an adorable array of children’s costumes that will make their Halloween night magical.

  • Abracadabra Superstore: Perfect for DIY enthusiasts
  • Halloween Adventure: Great selection of unique pieces
  • Ricky’s NYC & Party City: Ideal for ready-to-wear costumes
  • Rubie’s Costume Company & Frank Bee Costume Center: Best for children’s costumes

Whichever store you choose from our list, we’re certain that you’ll find just what you need to create a spine-chilling costume that will turn heads at every corner.

Remember folks – Halloween isn’t just a holiday; it’s an experience. So go out there and create some thrilling memories this October in The Big Apple! Happy haunting!

Scroll to Top